Best Four-Season Pad
NEMO Tensor All-Season
$230
R-value5.4
Weight17.0oz / 482g
InsulationSuspended metalized film
BafflesHorizontal
Thickness3.0in
Price$230
TrailCraft score 9.0/10
Read Full Review →Best Insulated Comfort
Exped Ultra 5R
$250
R-value4.8
Weight18.0oz / 510g
InsulationDown fill
BafflesVertical
Thickness3.0in
Price$250
TrailCraft score 8.8/10
Read Full Review →
Bottom line: The Tensor All-Season is warmer per ounce and cheaper, using suspended metalized film. The Exped uses down fill and vertical baffles, which produces a softer, flatter sleeping surface that many people prefer. Warmth and value: Tensor. Sleeping surface quality: Exped.
Head-to-head differences
Warmth
NEMO Tensor All-SeasonR-5.4 — genuine deep-winter capability
Exped Ultra 5RR-4.8 — three-season plus mild winter
Tensor wins.
Sleeping surface
NEMO Tensor All-SeasonHorizontal baffles create mild ridges across the body
Exped Ultra 5RVertical baffles run head to foot, giving a flatter feel
Exped wins, and it is noticeable.
Insulation type
NEMO Tensor All-SeasonFilm — unaffected by moisture, no drying concerns
Exped Ultra 5RDown — softer feel, and difficult to dry if water enters a puncture
Tensor wins on practicality; Exped on feel.
Price
NEMO Tensor All-Season$230
Exped Ultra 5R$250
Tensor wins.
Choose the NEMO Tensor All-Season if:
- →Deep winter camping where R-5.4 matters
- →You want the better value and higher warmth
- →You want no moisture concerns inside the pad
Choose the Exped Ultra 5R if:
- →Sleeping surface flatness matters most to you
- →You prefer the softer feel of down fill
- →R-4.8 is enough for your conditions
See all Best Backpacking Sleeping Pads reviews
Full rankings, specs, and scores for every product in this category.
View Full Category →Common Questions
Why does baffle direction matter?
Horizontal baffles run across your body and you feel the ridges under your spine. Vertical baffles run head to foot, producing a flatter surface. It is subtle until you have slept on both.
Is down inside a pad risky?
Only if the pad punctures and takes on water. Patch promptly and dry thoroughly if that happens; otherwise the down is sealed and stays dry.
Do I need R-5.4?
For snow camping and sustained sub-freezing nights, it helps. For three-season use, R-4 or above is generally sufficient.