Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our reviews are always our own honest opinion. Learn more.

Headlamp vs Lantern: Black Diamond Spot 400-R vs Moji R+ (2026)

A directed beam that follows your eyes against ambient light that fills a space. Most campers should own both, and here is which to buy first.

By William • Updated August 2026

Best Headlamp
Black Diamond Spot 400-R
$45
TypeHead-worn directed beam
Max output400 lumens
Weight3.0oz / 85g
Best forWalking, tasks, emergencies
WaterproofIPX8
Price$45
TrailCraft score 9.0/10
Read Full Review →
Best Tent Lantern
Black Diamond Moji R+
$50
TypeAmbient area light
Max output200 lumens
Weight5.3oz / 150g
Best forTents, tables, group areas
WaterproofIPX4
Price$50
TrailCraft score 8.9/10
Read Full Review →
Bottom line: Buy the headlamp first, always — it is the safety item and the only one that lets you walk out after dark. Add a lantern once you notice that eating dinner with four people wearing headlamps means everyone is blinding everyone else. Together they are $95 and cover every lighting situation at camp.

Head-to-head differences

Walking in the dark
Black Diamond Spot 400-REssential — light points where you look and leaves hands free
Black Diamond Moji R+Poor — an ambient light in your hand casts shadows and blinds you
Headlamp wins decisively; a lantern is not a substitute.
Group meals
Black Diamond Spot 400-RPoor — everyone looking at each other means everyone gets blinded
Black Diamond Moji R+Excellent — lights the table evenly with no glare
Lantern wins clearly.
Inside a tent
Black Diamond Spot 400-RWorkable, and the beam is harsh in a small space
Black Diamond Moji R+Better — diffuse light fills the tent without harsh shadows
Lantern wins.
Emergency use
Black Diamond Spot 400-RCritical — lets you hike out, signal, and work hands-free
Black Diamond Moji R+Limited
Headlamp wins.
Choose the Black Diamond Spot 400-R if:
  • →You are buying one light and it must be one light
  • →Any hiking after dark is possible
  • →You want the safety item first
Choose the Black Diamond Moji R+ if:
  • →You already own a headlamp
  • →Camp dinners and tent time dominate your camping
  • →You camp with a group and want to stop blinding each other

See all Best Camp Lanterns reviews

Full rankings, specs, and scores for every product in this category.

View Full Category →

Common Questions

If I can only buy one, which?
The headlamp, without hesitation. It is a safety item; a lantern is a comfort item.
Can a headlamp work as a lantern?
Partly. Strapping one around a water bottle full of water diffuses the beam into usable ambient light — a genuinely effective field trick.
Do I need a lantern at all for backpacking?
Most backpackers do not. The weight is hard to justify when a headlamp plus the water bottle trick covers ambient light adequately.
More Comparisons
← All gear comparisons